Is There a Real-World Alternative to Bukele on Crime?

It’s difficult to talk about public safety in Latin America today without talking about El Salvador and its president, Nayib Bukele. In a region where concerns about crime are running high, and organized crime groups are expanding their reach in many places, El Salvador stands out. Under Bukele’s watch, the country’s homicide and extortion rates have tumbled, and whole neighborhoods, once dominated by armed gangs, are now safe for residents to walk around.

But those results have come at a terrifying cost: tens of thousands imprisoned without due process, a constantly extended state of emergency, and acute concentration of power due to nonexistent checks and balances. Few pause to wonder if the gains against crime are sustainable, or to count up the costs to democracy and civil liberties. And El Salvador isn’t the only case that suggests that when living in fear, Latin American citizens are increasingly willing to sacrifice rights in exchange for safety. The percentage of people in our region willing to accept a non-democratic government if it resolved their problems increased from 46 per cent in 2016 to 51 per cent in 2023, according to Latinobarometro.

As politicians around the region make dubious promises to bring Bukele-style mano dura policies to their home countries, it’s worth asking—is there a workable alternative for Latin America today? Can public security be improved without a massive cost to individual rights?

The answer is a tentative yes. No model is flawless or automatically replicable, but in Guatemala, São Paulo, Brazil, and Bogotá, Colombia, a combination of effective investigation and punishment with social policies aimed at social inclusion has brought tangible results without compromising the rule of law. It’s worth looking at these examples to see how results were achieved.

[…]

READ THE FULL ARTICLE IN AMERICAS QUARTERLY

Suggested Content

Democracia en riesgo: la relación entre el dinero y la política

Una sana relación entre el dinero y la política es esencial para la salud democrática. Cómo regularla ha sido una preocupación de décadas en América

Venezuela’s Transition to Democracy, Still in Reach

A political transition can happen despite a flawed election and repression. The main challenge is providing incentives, within the rule of law, to those who

Citizen Security Should be a Central Focus of the 2025 Summit of the Americas

Last month, representatives from across the Western Hemisphere convened in the Dominican Republic to mark the thirtieth anniversary of the Summit of the Americas, a

Subscribe To
Latin America Advisors

* indicates required field

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

The Inter-American Dialogue Education Program

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER / SUSCRÍBASE A NUESTRO BOLETÍN:

* indicates required