Mexican security forces on Sept. 6 detained 14 people, including a senior officer of Mexico’s navy, in connection with authorities’ seizure in March of a ship carrying 63,000 barrels of diesel fuel from the United States. Prosecutors have alleged that the navy officers had operated a scheme to avoid import taxes on the fuel. How big of a problem is contraband fuel in Mexico? What do the arrests say about Mexican authorities’ pursuit of such corruption schemes? What kinds of efforts are needed to prevent future cases of fuel theft?
José Carlos Rodríguez Pueblita, professor of business economics at the IPADE Business School in Mexico City: “Fuel theft and contraband fuel have become one of Mexico’s most pressing organized crime challenges, extending far beyond traditional illicit activities like drug trafficking. While earlier efforts reduced pipeline theft through military deployment and supply monitoring, the problem adapted and shifted into more sophisticated channels, including maritime contraband and tax evasion schemes that cost the Mexican treasury about $24 million per day, according to PetroIntelligence, a Mexican consulting firm specialized in the sector. The September arrests, involving navy officers accused of facilitating untaxed diesel imports, highlight both the depth of the problem and the complexity of addressing it. They show that corruption networks can penetrate even high-trust institutions, but also signal that the current administration is willing to act against such abuses, regardless of the risks to institutional reputation—a contrast with the previous administration. Looking ahead, tackling fuel contraband requires a three-pronged approach. The first is greater transparency and digital monitoring of imports, customs operations and fuel distribution chains, with data cross-checks between Pemex, tax authorities and independent auditors. Second is institutional reforms that reduce discretion and strengthen accountability within the armed forces and energy regulators. Third is closer coordination between Mexican and U.S. authorities. The current administration faces both an opportunity and a dilemma: pursuing such cases demonstrates a real commitment to the rule of law and signals seriousness to the U.S. government in the fight against organized crime, but politically it may expose vulnerabilities from the prior government’s strategies and teams. By moving forward decisively, President Sheinbaum can consolidate her leadership and affirm her role as commander-in-chief, though at the risk of distancing herself from her predecessor. Nevertheless, it is a challenge worth undertaking.”
Pamela Cruz, editor-in-chief of the Mexican Press Agency: “The recent arrest of a navy admiral and other senior officials for their alleged involvement in a fuel smuggling network (huachicol fiscal) exposes the scale of the problem: Mexico loses billions of dollars annually to sophisticated criminal schemes that evade taxes, use falsified documents and rely on the complicity of both public and private actors. In the face of this reality, President Claudia Sheinbaum has drawn a clear line: Her administration has reiterated a policy of ‘zero impunity’ and made it clear that no official, regardless of rank, is above the law. This case is neither incidental nor isolated. It is part of a broader federal strategy to dismantle corruption networks that drain public finances and erode trust in institutions. By emphasizing that the investigation spanned two years and that every seizure was used to build a solid case, Sheinbaum shows this is not about media spectacle but about rigorous technical and judicial follow-up. To prevent future cases, arrests must be paired with structural reforms: full traceability of fuel from import to sale, greater transparency at customs and ports, stricter internal controls in the armed forces and a stronger anti-corruption system capable of sanctioning all parties involved, both business and government. Sheinbaum’s message could not be clearer: The looting of public resources will not be tolerated, and her government is prepared to go as far as it takes to eradicate it.”
Andrés Rozental, member of the Advisor board, president of Rozental & Asociados and former deputy foreign minister of Mexico: “The contraband fuel scandal continues to make headlines in Mexico as authorities uncover more and more individuals suspected of having participated in the tax avoidance scheme that netted millions of dollars for those involved. The 14 original suspects, including very senior naval officers, have now been joined by others from the ruling party that are presumed to have been part of a wholesale effort to defraud the country’s tax authority of huge sums that normally would be paid on imports of gasoline. Fuel imports under the scheme were mis-classed as lubricants or other hydrocarbon derivative products that are tariff-free in Mexico. Theft of gasoline through illegal pipeline punctures, or from Pemex refineries, has been an ongoing problem for authorities for the last decade. The amount of gasoline coming from these criminal activities is significant and is often clandestinely distributed within Mexico at prices below those at service stations. Stolen fuel has also been transported illegally to the United States and then imported back to Mexico without the payment of duty if originating in a country like the United States that has a free trade agreement with Mexico. Thus, stolen gasoline that hasn’t cost the thieves anything can be brought back to Mexico and sold at tremendous profit. Although this illegal activity has been around for many years, the principal importance of what the Mexican authorities are now doing by dismantling the criminal organizations that have benefited from the ’huachicol’ scheme, and arresting dozens of suspected individuals involved, is that President Sheinbaum has openly addressed the issue and promised to go after everyone found to be suspected of involvement, notwithstanding the fact that some were navy higher-ups, and others part of the López Obrador administration. This clearly signals a break in Sheinbaum’s commitment to keep AMLO, his colleagues and even his family out of any suspected corruption during his administration.”
Cecilia Farfán-Méndez, head of the North American Observatory at the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime: “Fuel theft is certainly not a new phenomenon in Mexico’s criminal landscape. In 2011, Pemex sued U.S. companies for purchasing stolen fuel from criminal groups. The Trump administration, however, renewed the attention on this criminal activity with the alert issued by the U.S. Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) in May of this year. In that alert, FinCEN urged ’financial institutions to be vigilant’ and explained that ‘cartels were using complicit Mexican brokers in the oil and natural gas industry to smuggle and sell crude oil stolen from Pemex to complicit, small U.S.-based oil and natural gas companies operating near the southwest border.’ While combating corruption has been a central motto for Morena, there have been few high-profile cases that have been prosecuted. These arrests could be a step in the right direction in terms of signaling that the Sheinbaum government is willing and able to prosecute corruption cases linked with criminal activities even if they involve personnel from the armed forces. But arrests alone are not sufficient. Mexico has executed high-level arrests only to be followed by questionable dismissals. What is needed, to send a strong message around these corruption schemes, is a proper criminal proceeding. While I do not think there is a one-size-fits-all approach, an important element to highlight with these cases is the transnational nature of the crimes. As the FinCEN alert highlighted, this activity generally involves actors on both sides of the border. Therefore, robust cooperation between Mexico and the United States is a key component of identifying and prosecuting these criminal activities.”
Ruben Olmos, chief executive officer of Global Nexus LLC: “The fuel contraband in Mexico known as ‘huachicol fiscal’ is a top national security threat and a major challenge for the Sheinbaum administration, as it involves dangerous criminal groups presumably protected by top elected and public officials including governors, mayors and officials in the security cabinet. President Sheinbaum’s unprecedented actions, carried out by her closest cabinet member, federal public security secretary Omar García Harfuch and the attorney general against top leadership of the navy mark a historic move to persecute members of an elite institution that most Mexicans respect. The wide network of corrupt members of the navy and officials in customs and ports has left the president with no alternative but to dismantle it and expose many politicians who were presumably protected by former President López Obrador. In recent weeks, President Sheinbaum has shown signs that she is willing to break with the past, knowing well there are risks to that but at the same time designing her legacy and taking over the country as head of the armed forces.”
The Latin America Advisor features Q&A from leaders in politics, economics, and finance every business day. It is available to members of the Dialogue’s Corporate Program and others by subscription.
